Not everyone who becomes a family caregiver feels naturally suited to the role.
Some people are uncomfortable with the physical side of caregiving. Others are balancing careers, children, finances or lives hundreds of miles away. And for many, caring for an aging parent brings old family tensions back to the surface.
Joy Johnston knows that experience well.
A journalist and Gen Xer, Joy became a long-distance caregiver when her father's dementia progressed and later uprooted her life in Atlanta to care for her mother in New Mexico following major cancer surgery. Her memoir, The Reluctant Caregiver: Missives from the Caregiving Minefields, explores a part of caregiving that people don't always feel comfortable admitting: you can love someone, make sure they receive good care and still feel reluctant about becoming their caregiver.
“I wasn't reluctant in the act of caring, but that doesn't mean I was excited to be there doing all of the grueling tasks of a caregiver,” Joy says.
Her experience offers an honest look at caregiver guilt, strained family relationships, long-distance care and what happens when a role you never expected becomes one of the biggest responsibilities of your life.
Becoming a Caregiver Before You Feel Ready
Joy knew that caring for her parents was probably somewhere in her future. They were older than the parents of most of her peers, and they had retired to New Mexico while she lived in Atlanta.
Still, caregiving felt far away.
She was in her 30s and focused on a fast-paced career. Her parents' aging felt, as she describes it, like a storm sitting offshore: something she knew would eventually arrive but didn't yet have the time or emotional space to confront.
That changed as her father's behavior began to shift.
There wasn't one dramatic moment when dementia appeared. Instead, Joy heard about a series of small changes during weekly conversations with her mother. Her father had trouble handling money. He became suspicious that people were trying to cheat him. His driving deteriorated.
Then came a moment that made the situation impossible to dismiss. Her father walked into a convenience store, picked up food and tried to leave without paying. It was completely out of character.
For Joy, that was when the possibility of dementia became something the family had to actively address.
Long-Distance Caregiving Can Make Every Decision Harder
Living across the country made an already complicated situation more difficult.
Joy describes herself during this period as a long-distance caregiver. Most of what she knew about her father's condition came through phone calls with her mother. She wasn't always able to see what was happening firsthand, and her mother tended to put an optimistic spin on difficult situations.
That left Joy trying to interpret what was really happening from thousands of miles away.
“There were times, frankly, when I avoided going home because it was stressful,” she says.
That honesty matters because long-distance caregiving can involve guilt alongside genuine logistical limits. Being far away can make every choice feel reactive, especially when you're relying on someone else to tell you how serious a situation has become.
Eventually, an emergency hospitalization changed everything.
Her father underwent surgery and lost the ability to walk during his recovery. Because her parents lived in a condo with stairs and there was no practical way to make the home accessible for him, the hospital could not discharge him back home.
He was sent to rehabilitation and later moved to a memory-care community about an hour and a half away because closer facilities couldn't accommodate his needs.
For Joy's mother, the distance created another problem: she didn't drive. Visiting her husband meant a long bus trip in each direction.
The experience taught Joy that aging in place depends on much more than whether someone wants to remain home.
Housing, transportation, medical services, accessibility and the availability of local care all matter.
Rural Caregiving Creates Its Own Challenges
Joy's parents lived in a small community in New Mexico, and the limitations of rural healthcare became increasingly apparent as their needs grew.
Specialists weren't always available locally. Some services required significant travel. Care communities had limited openings, and home-care options were scarce.
Later, when her mother needed rehabilitation after cancer surgery, Joy again found herself trying to navigate limited local choices while under enormous pressure.
She now encourages families to investigate those issues before a crisis happens.
If your parents plan to age in place, ask practical questions early:
- What medical services are available nearby?
- How far away are specialists?
- What home-care services operate in the area?
- Are there rehabilitation or skilled-nursing facilities nearby?
- What transportation options exist if someone can no longer drive?
- Could the home accommodate a walker or wheelchair if mobility changes?
A home may work perfectly well today and become difficult to navigate after one hospitalization or injury.
Caring for Aging Parents When Your Relationship Is Complicated
One of the most powerful parts of Joy's story is her willingness to talk honestly about her relationship with her parents.
They were good people, she says, but they weren't especially close.
There were times when she avoided visiting because going home was stressful. During her father's illness, her mother's weekly calls sometimes became long conversations filled with worry and frustration. Joy was also dealing with her own problems, including career pressure and financial stress during the 2008 recession.
Looking back, she wishes she had been more sympathetic to what her mother was experiencing. But she also recognizes that both of them were under tremendous pressure.
Later, when Joy became her mother's hands-on caregiver, those unresolved relationship dynamics didn't simply disappear.
“My mother and I were like oil and water — totally different personalities,” Joy says.
That is an important reality for caregivers who feel guilty because their relationship with a parent doesn't resemble the warm, uncomplicated relationship often portrayed in caregiving stories.
A complicated relationship can remain complicated even when someone becomes sick.
Caregiving doesn't erase old resentments, personality differences or difficult family history. It simply adds a new responsibility on top of them.
Joy's perspective now is that a strained relationship doesn't mean caregiving is impossible.
“My point in writing the book was hopefully to allow other people to recognize that it's okay if you have a strained relationship with your loved ones that you're caring for — you can still manage it.”
And if you reach a point where you can't manage it, she adds, that's when outside help becomes especially important.
What Does It Mean to Be a Reluctant Caregiver?
When Joy chose The Reluctant Caregiver as the title of her book, some members of her writing group worried that the phrase sounded too negative.
For Joy, it was simply accurate.
She never considered herself a natural caregiver. She was uncomfortable with some of the intimate physical tasks involved and worried that she wasn't equipped to handle them.
When her mother returned home following cancer surgery, Joy found herself doing things she never imagined she would have to do, including helping manage her mother's colostomy.
She learned much of what she needed to know as she went.
The reluctance wasn't about whether her parents deserved care. It was about whether she felt capable of providing that care herself.
“I was afraid of failing, because I felt like it was so out of my league,” she says.
That distinction matters.
You can be reluctant to perform intimate caregiving tasks and still care deeply about the person. You can resent the circumstances without resenting your parent. And you can decide that some responsibilities are better handled by a professional caregiver without abandoning someone you love.
Caregiver Guilt Doesn't Mean You Don't Care
Caregiving can produce contradictory emotions.
Joy sometimes wished she could get away. She needed breaks from her mother, and she believes her mother probably needed breaks from her too.
At the same time, she is grateful she was able to provide that care.
She eventually quit her job, left her home in Atlanta and spent months in New Mexico helping her mother through rehabilitation and recovery. She believes being physically present helped her advocate for her mother's care in ways she couldn't have done from a distance.
Their relationship remained difficult at times, but it also changed.
By the end of her mother's life, Joy felt that some of the tension between them had softened.
“There were definitely good moments,” she says. “Ultimately, I know my mom was very appreciative of the care that I provided, and I know she needed it.”
She doesn't pretend the difficult parts never happened. Instead, she believes time gave her more perspective on both her parents and herself.
Her message to other caregivers is that guilt doesn't need to be proof that you're doing something wrong. Sometimes guilt reflects the fact that you're navigating a difficult responsibility with a complicated person under circumstances neither of you chose.
Why Caregivers Need Respite
One thing Joy would change about her caregiving experience is taking more breaks.
“There were definitely times that I wish I could have stepped away or at least have gotten more of a break,” she says. “I think that would have been good for me and my mother. I think we needed a break from each other.”
There were people in her mother's community who could have stayed with her for a few hours, giving Joy time to walk, read in a café or simply be somewhere else.
She rarely took advantage of that help.
“I needed more breaks,” she says.
Looking back, she became a strong advocate for respite care because she believes both she and her mother would have benefited.
Respite doesn't have to mean taking a weeklong vacation. It can mean another family member staying for an afternoon, hiring a caregiver for several hours or using a local respite program.
The goal is to create enough separation that caregiving doesn't consume every part of the caregiver's life.
For someone already struggling with reluctance, resentment or exhaustion, even a short break can provide the emotional distance needed to return more patiently.
Plan for Aging Parents Before There's a Crisis
One of Joy's strongest pieces of advice is also one she wishes she had followed herself: talk about elder care before you urgently need it.
“I think it's really important for people to think about elder-care issues before they face it on a personal level,” she says. “It's always easier to do it beforehand.”
Families often postpone these conversations because they're uncomfortable.
But questions about healthcare wishes, finances, housing and end-of-life care become much harder to resolve when someone is already hospitalized or seriously ill.
Joy recommends discussing questions such as:
- Is there a will?
- Who can make healthcare decisions if necessary?
- What are your parent's wishes for end-of-life care?
- Where would they want to live if living independently became difficult?
- Could their current home accommodate changing mobility?
- What care services exist in their community?
- Who nearby could realistically help?
- What can the family afford?
These conversations don't require predicting every possible scenario.
The goal is simply to understand someone's preferences before other people are forced to guess.
Think Honestly About Aging in Place
Most people would prefer to remain in their own homes as they age, but Joy's experience taught her that wanting to age in place and being able to do so successfully aren't always the same thing.
Her father's hospitalization changed his mobility almost overnight. Suddenly, a home with stairs that had worked for years was no longer appropriate.
Families should consider the physical home as well as the surrounding community.
Can someone live primarily on one floor? Is the bathroom accessible? What happens if driving is no longer possible? Are home-care workers available locally? How far away is the nearest hospital?
Joy puts it simply: “Really think about the amount of support you or your loved ones have in their community.”
Thinking about these questions early doesn't mean someone has to move.
It simply gives the family more options if circumstances change.
The Financial Cost of Family Caregiving
Caregiving affected Joy's finances long after her hands-on responsibilities ended.
She left her job to care for her mother and relied partly on freelance work. That meant losing income as well as time she otherwise would have spent contributing to retirement savings.
She also accumulated credit-card debt paying expenses associated with caregiving.
“Caregiving is expensive,” she says. “It is so expensive.”
Years later, she was still dealing with the financial consequences.
She describes eventually getting close to paying off caregiving-related credit-card debt five years after her mother's death, while also recognizing that the year she spent out of the traditional workforce affected her retirement savings.
It's one reason Joy believes families should talk about money as part of caregiving planning rather than waiting until expenses begin accumulating.
Those conversations might include:
- What care can the older adult afford?
- What does insurance cover?
- What costs might family members need to absorb?
- Could a caregiver reduce work hours or leave a job?
- What would lost income mean for that person's own retirement?
- Are there local or government programs that could help?
Family caregiving may be unpaid, but it is rarely free.
When Is It Okay to Bring in Outside Help?
One of the most important lessons Joy learned is that caring for someone doesn't require doing every task personally.
Some people naturally take to hands-on caregiving. Others don't.
A caregiver may be uncomfortable with personal-care tasks, lack the physical ability to safely assist someone or simply reach the point where the responsibility has become too much.
That doesn't mean they've failed.
Joy believes caregivers need to be honest about what they can reasonably provide.
“It's okay to be a reluctant caregiver,” she says. “That doesn't mean that your loved one doesn't deserve good care, and you need to decide whether you can provide that care or you feel you need to get outside help.”
That may be one of the most important distinctions in her entire story.
If the quality of care begins to suffer because you are overwhelmed, resentful or unable to perform certain tasks, bringing in outside help may be better for everyone.
That help could mean a few hours of home care, respite services, assistance from other family members or eventually a residential care community.
The important question isn't whether you are personally doing everything.
It's whether the person you care about is getting the support they need.
Caregiving Changed Joy's Life in an Unexpected Way
Joy began writing about caregiving before her father's death.
As a journalist, writing was her natural way of processing grief. After he died, she created The Memories Project and initially set herself a goal of writing one memory about her father every day for a year.
The project grew into something larger.
Over time, she began writing more broadly about Alzheimer's disease, dementia care and family caregiving. Her experience eventually led her into caregiver advocacy.
“If there's one thing I can take away from my caregiving experience for my parents, it's that I've become a caregiver advocate,” she says.
The role she once approached reluctantly became an important part of her life's work.
That doesn't mean she looks back on caregiving as easy or believes everyone should find a greater purpose in it.
Instead, she hopes her willingness to talk about the difficult parts makes other caregivers feel less isolated.
It's Okay to Be a Reluctant Caregiver
There is a version of caregiving that we often like to tell: someone willingly puts everything aside to care for a parent out of pure love and gratitude.
Sometimes that happens.
But caregiving can also arrive in the middle of a career, from across the country, after years of a difficult parent-child relationship and with no training whatsoever.
You may love your parent and hate caregiving.
You may be grateful for the time together and desperately need time away.
You may do things you never imagined you could do and still wish someone else could take over for an afternoon.
Those feelings can exist at the same time.
Being reluctant doesn't mean someone deserves less care. It means you may need to be more intentional about what you can provide yourself, where you need support and how to protect your own well-being along the way.
As Joy's experience shows, good caregiving doesn't require being a natural caregiver.
Sometimes it starts with simply being honest about the kind of caregiver you are.
About Joy Johnston
Joy Johnston is a journalist, writer and caregiver advocate. After caring for both of her parents, she wrote The Reluctant Caregiver: Missives from the Caregiving Minefields, which explores the emotional, physical and financial realities of family caregiving. She also founded The Memories Project, which began as a tribute to her father and evolved into a platform focused on Alzheimer's disease, dementia and caregiver issues.
-
Black Friday SaleBig-Grip No-Slip Compression Socks: 3-PackRegular price $22Regular priceUnit price per$54Sale price $22Black Friday Sale -
Black Friday SaleCareZips® Men's Access PantsRegular price $70Regular priceUnit price per$108Sale price $70Black Friday Sale -
Black Friday SaleCareZips® Women's Access PantsRegular price $70Regular priceUnit price per$108Sale price $70Black Friday Sale -
Black Friday SaleEveryday Gripper Socks 3-PackRegular price $35Regular priceUnit price per$54Sale price $35Black Friday Sale -
Black Friday SaleEveryday Magnetic Button-Down for Men | Tailored-FitRegular price $70Regular priceUnit price per$108Sale price $70Black Friday Sale -
Black Friday SaleEveryday Magnetic Flannel for MenRegular price $70Regular priceUnit price per$108Sale price $70Black Friday Sale -
Black Friday SaleEveryday Magnetic Flannel for WomenRegular price $70Regular priceUnit price per$108Sale price $70Black Friday Sale -
Black Friday SaleEveryday Side-Zip Pants for MenRegular price $70Regular priceUnit price per$108Sale price $70Black Friday Sale -
Black Friday SaleEveryday Side-Zip Pants for WomenRegular price $70Regular priceUnit price per$108Sale price $70Black Friday Sale -
Black Friday SaleHoodEase®: The Magnetic Zip-Up HoodieRegular price $70Regular priceUnit price per$108Sale price $70Black Friday Sale -
Black Friday SaleHoodEase®: The Magnetic Zip-Up Hoodie for WomenRegular price $70Regular priceUnit price per$108Sale price $70Black Friday Sale -
Black Friday SaleMagnetic Button-Down for Men | Relaxed-FitRegular price $70Regular priceUnit price per$108Sale price $70Black Friday Sale -
Black Friday SaleShort-Sleeve Everyday Magnetic-Button Shirt for MenRegular price $70Regular priceUnit price per$108Sale price $70Black Friday Sale -
Black Friday SaleSignature Magnetic Cardigan for WomenRegular price $76Regular priceUnit price per$118Sale price $76Black Friday Sale -
Black Friday SaleSignature Magnetic Zip-Up Sweater For MenRegular price $76Regular priceUnit price per$118Sale price $76Black Friday Sale -
Black Friday SaleSignature Side-Zip Chinos for MenRegular price $76Regular priceUnit price per$118Sale price $76Black Friday Sale















